How Does Stock Compensation Fit into Your Financial Plan?
Stock compensation has become an increasingly common way to recruit and retain employees. While it was traditionally thought of as a way to award high-ranking executives, it has become very common for employees at all levels in tech companies. It can also be a lucrative part of your compensation package that helps you achieve financial goals. To get the most out of stock compensation, it’s important to understand how it works and how it fits into your personal financial plan.
This month I have a guest blog post from Chloe Moore, CFP®, founder of Financial Staples, a virtual fee-only comprehensive financial planning firm based in Atlanta, GA and serving clients nationwide. To learn how to get the most out of stock compensation and why it’s important to understand how it fits into your financial plan, read Chloe’s post below and also tune in to episode 008 of my podcast, where I interview Chloe and she shares this valuable information.
What is Stock Compensation?
Stock compensation is a component of your total compensation. In addition to a salary, cash bonuses, and benefits, some employees may receive stock in their company. This component can sometimes be negotiated just like you negotiate your cash compensation and benefits.
Types of Stock Compensation
While there are many types of stock compensation, two of the most common are stock options and restricted stock units.
A stock option is the right to buy shares of company stock for a fixed price (“exercise price”) during a fixed period of time (usually 10 years). There are two types of stock options: Non-qualified stock options (“NQSOs”) and Incentive stock options (“ISOs”), and they differ in their tax treatment.
The value of stock options is determined by the difference between the exercise price and the current value of the stock. If the current price of the stock is above the exercise price, the stock option has value, commonly known as “in the money.” If the current price of the stock is below the exercise price, the stock option has no value.
Example: Your company gives you the right to buy 1,000 shares of company stock for $20/share. If the current price of the stock is $50/share, your option allows you to buy it for $30/share less than the market price. If the current price of the stock is $10, your option has no value because it’s cheaper to buy the stock in the open market.
Stock options are subject to what’s called vesting. This is the time you must wait before you can exercise your options. In most cases, companies require you to work for the company for 3 to 5 years. Your options can vest all at once or gradually over that time period. Once they vest, you will have to decide when to exercise, how to exercise, and when to sell the stock.
A restricted stock unit, or RSU, is your company’s promise to give you shares of stock in the company as soon as certain conditions are met. The most common condition is time with the company, but the condition could also be certain performance metrics. Getting an RSU is like getting a cash bonus and using that cash to buy company stock. The key difference between RSUs and stock options is that RSUs always have value as long as the company has value. As a result, the risk is higher with stock options than with RSUs.
Example: Your company promises to give you 1,000 shares of stock. To receive the shares of stock currently valued at $25,000 ($25 per share), you must stay with the company for 4 years.
Restricted Stock Units are also subject to vesting, in this case it is the time you must wait before you own and can sell your stock. Once your RSUs vest, you will have to decide when to sell the stock.
When deciding when to exercise or when to sell your company stock, there are several considerations that will influence your decisions on how to best manage the stock. It is important to think about your goals and how this additional income can help you reach your goals. After all, stock compensation is just another form of compensation, similar to a cash bonus.
One of the major considerations with stock compensation is taxes. With stock options, the difference between the exercise price and the stock price on the exercise date (the “spread”) is taxable. The tax impact varies based on whether you have ISOs or NQSOs. In addition, the difference between the value on the date you sell the stock and the value of the stock on the exercise date is taxable as a capital gain or loss. The tax impact varies based on whether the gain or loss is short term or long term.
Example: In our previous example where the stock price at exercise was $50/share and the exercise price was $20/share, the difference of $30/share is taxable. If you later sell the stock after it has increased to $75/share, the difference between $75 and $50 is taxable as a capital gain.
Restricted stock units are taxable as ordinary income on the day they vest, just like your salary or a cash bonus. When you sell the stock, the difference between the value on the date you sell the stock and the value of the stock on the date you receive the stock is taxable as a capital gain or loss. The tax impact varies based on whether the gain or loss is short term or long term.
Example: In our previous example where you received 1,000 shares of company stock valued at $25/share, $25,000 is taxed as regular income. When you sell the stock, the difference between the value when you sell the stock and the value when you received the stock is taxable as a capital gain or loss.
Taxes may be withheld at exercise (for stock options) or on the day they vest (for restricted stock). In some cases, the amount withheld may not be enough, and you may owe additional IRS and state taxes on April 15th. You may also be subject to payroll taxes, which includes Social Security and Medicare taxes.
- Employment Status
There are rules around what happens to your stock options or restricted stock units if you leave your job, become disabled, or die. Always read your documents carefully to make sure you understand the terms of your agreement.
- Investment Risks
It is very common for people to accumulate stock in their company because they don’t understand how stock compensation works or they avoid making a decision. Having a large portion of your net worth in your company stock can be risky. Remember, don’t put all your eggs in one basket!
Public vs. Private companies
Public companies are companies that can be traded by the general public on stock exchanges. Private companies are generally owned and traded by the company’s founders, management, employees, or private investors. A private company can become a public company by selling all or a portion of itself through an initial public offering (IPO).
Stock options – With a public company, you’re eligible to exercise your stock options as soon as they vest. Some private companies allow you to exercise your stock options before the company goes public. This is called “early exercise” and it should be considered carefully.
Restricted stock units – The main difference between public company RSUs and private company RSUs is when they fully vest. With a public company, the stock will vest as long as you work for the company for the time required or if certain performance metrics are met. With a private company, you generally have to meet the time or performance metrics and the company has to have a change in control. This change in control could mean the company goes public (IPO) or there is a merger or acquisition.
These days most public companies and late stage private companies offer RSUs and private or early stage companies offer stock options. Be careful with private company stock compensation, as it’s not always a home run. Not every private company decides to go public and not every IPO is successful!
- Think of stock options and restricted stock units as part of your total compensation in addition to your salary, benefits, cash bonuses. Don’t be afraid to negotiate stock compensation just like you negotiate your cash compensation and benefits.
- Make sure you read your documents so you can understand how things work and how it impacts you.
- Consult with a qualified financial planner and tax professional who are familiar with stock compensation. They can help you understand job offers and how to best manage your stock compensation.
- Consider Your Options by Kaye A. Thomas
- Wealthfront Blog Guide to Equity & IPOs
- Financial Staples/Chloe Moore:
- Website: http://www.financialstaples.com/
- LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/chloemoore
- Twitter: https://twitter.com/finstaples
- Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/finstaples
Have a Question?
Send me an email at Luis@onmywaytowealth.com and let’s get started on pursuing your financial goals together. To get bi-monthly financial tips for Gen Xers sign up for my newsletter and subscribe to the podcast.
Investment Advisor Representative of Retirement Wealth Advisors Inc. (RWA), 89 Ionia NW, Suite 600, Grand Rapids, MI 49503 (800) 903-2562. Investment Advisory Services are offered through RWA. Build a Better Financial Future and RWA are not affiliated.